Overview 40%
of the Series 63 examination (24 questions) covers prohibited actions by broker dealers and their agents; and investment advisers and their representatives (IARs). This is the largest portion of the examination and must be studied thoroughly.
Advisory Contract and Anti-Fraud Rules Under the Act, it is unlawful for any person who receives compensation, directly or indirectly, for advising as the value of securities or their purchase or sale, whether through the issuance of analyses, reports or otherwise, to: Employ any device, scheme, or artifice to defraud; Engage in an act, practice or course of business which operates or would operate as a fraud or deceit on any person; Effect a transaction for a customer, as broker or dealer, without obtaining the consent of the customer to such transaction; Engage in any dishonest or unethical practice as the Administrator may define by rule. NASAA Advisory Contract Rule 502 (c) NASAA, under Model Rule 502 (c), requires that advisory contracts with customers must: be in writing; have a fixed life (e.g., 1 year; 2 years); Can Accept Prepaid Advisory Fees detail the advisory fee to be paid - note that prepayment of fees is permitted (such as paying for 6 months of advice up-front); Early Termination - Refund Prepaid Fees detail the refund of any prepaid advisory fee to be made if the contract is terminated early; provide that no assignment can be made unless the customer approves. Cannot Assign Contract Unless Client Approves Furthermore, investment advisers are prohibited from entering into, or extending, an advisory contract, unless it provides in writing that: No Compensation Based On Gain/Loss the investment adviser shall not be compensated on the basis of capital gains or capital appreciation of funds in the account (however, it is permitted for compensation to be based on the total value of all assets being managed); Notify Customer of Changes in Partnership Composition if the investment adviser is a partnership, the customer shall be notified within a reasonable time of any changes in partnership membership. A change in a majority of the partners is an assignment that requires customer consent. (Also note that if an advisory contract is assigned from one IAR at a firm to another IAR at the same firm, this is not an assignment of the contract, since the contract was not moved to another firm.) Regarding compensation, the adviser can charge a percentage of assets under management, using a schedule that gives a declining percentage fee as client assets increase. The adviser can also use a negotiated fee basis, as long as it is consistently applied. Wealthy Clients Can Be Charged a Performance Fee An exception to the rule prohibiting compensation based on gains is given to advisers that have very wealthy customers (defined as a customer with either $1.1 million of assets under management with the adviser or a $2.2 million net worth). In this case, the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 allows a performance fee, and Federal law has supremacy over State law. Rule 502 (c) Applies to State Registered Advisers and Federal Covered Advisers if There Is Fraud A final note on NASAA Rule 502 (c): The rule applies to State registered advisers because it is a NASAA rule, and it also applies to Federal covered advisers only to the extent that the alleged conduct is fraudulent or deceptive (this is a test point). NASAA Required Disclosures if Performance Fee Is Charged NASAA requires that if an adviser charges a performance fee, it must disclose in writing: that the fee arrangement may create an incentive for the adviser to make investments that are riskier; that the investment adviser will get compensation based on both unrealized appreciation and capital gains; the basis for valuing any illiquid investments used in computing unrealized appreciation; the periods that will be used to measure performance and their significance to the computation of the fee; and the nature of an index used as a comparison of investment performance, the significance of the index and the reasons why the adviser believes the index is appropriate. Wrap Fees, Commissions Advisers can take "compensation" in other ways as well. They can earn "wrap" fees that wrap all services, including the cost of all trades, into a single annual fee - either as a flat dollar amount or as a percentage of assets under management. If an adviser has an affiliated broker-dealer, it may send its trades to this firm, and commissions may be earned by the affiliated broker-dealer (but this must be disclosed to the IA's clients). Advisers can also earn so-called "soft dollars." Soft Dollars A "soft-dollar" arrangement is where an adviser sends its portfolio trades to a brokerage firm that does not discount commissions, which, on its face, would raise costs to its clients and would violate the IA's fiduciary requirement to act in the clients' best interests. However, as a "quid pro quo," the broker "gives back" to the adviser research reports, asset allocation software, stock selection software, etc. In theory, these items should allow the adviser to do a better job for their customers. The SEC and NASAA permit soft dollar arrangements with the proviso that the "give-backs" benefit the adviser's clients - not the advise 12b-1 Fees Another fee that an adviser can collect is a portion of a 12b-1 fee. SEC Rule 12b-1 permits investment companies to charge their shareholders an annual fee (capped at 1% annually) where the proceeds are used to pay for the cost of getting new investment into the fund. An investment adviser that agrees to place money in a mutual fund can share in these annual fees. No Hedge Clauses That Are Either Unreasonable or That Seek to Hold Adviser Harmless for Violations Advisory contracts cannot contain "hedge clauses" that seek to eliminate the adviser's liability for negative investment results, except due to events beyond that adviser's control such as war, terrorist acts, etc. In addition, such "exculpatory" clauses cannot be used to "get around" the adviser contract rules. For example, the adviser cannot use such a clause to take a portion of gains and losses in an account, and the customer agrees to "hold the adviser harmless" for doing so. NASAA Investment Adviser Brochure Delivery Rule, Form ADV Part 2A, Form ADV Part 2B NASAA requires that any new customer be provided with a copy of the adviser's "Brochure" and "Brochure Supplement" when entering into an advisory contract. This is a copy of Form ADV Part 2A (the "Brochure") which gives information about the adviser's business; and Form ADV Part 2B (the "Brochure Supplement") which gives information about the adviser's key personnel. These are the SEC investment adviser registration forms which are also used by each State for State-registered advisers. Brochure Delivery Under NASAA Rules, the Form ADV Part 2A ("Brochure") and Part 2B ("Brochure Supplement") must be delivered to customers: 2 Day Free Look Before Signing no less than 48 hours prior to entering into either an oral or written advisory contract with a customer (a "2 day free look") - meaning the customer gets the Brochure and Supplement 48 hours prior to signing the contract; or alternatively If No Free Look, 5 Days to Rescind the customer can sign the contract and be given the Brochure and Supplement, and then has 5 business days to terminate without penalty. (Note: This is the NASAA rule - the SEC rule under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 is NOT the same - it simply requires delivery of the Brochure and Supplement, at or prior to, entering into any advisory contract.) Annual Brochure Update - if Changes Are Material - Send to Customers At the end of each year, NASAA requires that if there is a material change in the Brochure, it must be provided to existing customers within 120 days of the adviser's fiscal year end (this is the same as the SEC rule). Firm Can Create Its Own Brochure, Brochure Can Be Delivered Electronically Note that rather than giving a "boring" document that is filed with the State as the Brochure, the adviser can create its own "livelier" more colorful version, as long as all of the same information is presented. NASAA also states that electronic delivery of the Brochure and Supplement to customers is permitted. Custody Rules Finally, it is prohibited for an investment adviser to have, or take custody of, customer funds and securities: If the Administrator prohibits this by rule; or If there is no rule, the adviser fails to notify the Administrator that he has, or may take custody. If an investment adviser wishes to take custody of client funds or securities, NASAA requires that: Notice to Administrator It must notify the Administrator in writing on Form ADV (this is the form that advisers use to register with the SEC; and is also used by each State for adviser registration) that it has, or may have, custody; Securities Held by Qualified Custodian Custody must be kept by a qualified custodian in a separate account under each client name; or in accounts that only contain client funds and securities, held in investment adviser name as trustee for the clients; Prompt Notice to Customer of Custodian Identity Prompt notice must be given to the clients in writing of the qualified custodian's name, address, and the manner in which the funds or securities are maintained; Quarterly Statements Account statements must be sent at least quarterly to clients; and Annual Surprise Audit of Custodian The qualified custodian must be audited on a surprise basis at least annually to verify all client funds and securities. File Audit Results Within 120 Days The investment adviser must file a copy of the audit results with the State Administrator within 120 days of completion of the audit. Qualified Custodian Registration Qualified custodians under NASAA's Custody Rule are: FDIC insured deposit-taking institutions; Registered broker-dealers holding customer assets; Registered futures commission merchants holding customer assets; and Foreign financial institutions holding financial assets for customers. Custody Definition Note that the definition of taking "custody" includes not only accepting customer funds or securities, but also includes: Prepaid Advisory Fees of $500 or More the acceptance of prepaid advisory fees of $500 or more, 6 months or more in advance of rendering services (Note 1); or Account with Full Power of Attorney an account that gives a full power of attorney to the adviser, which would allow the adviser to withdraw funds (Note 2). (Note 1: The Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (Federal law) sets the dollar limit for being defined as "taking custody" at a higher level - $1,200 - for Federal Covered Advisers. State law sets it at the lower $500 level for State-registered advisers.) (Note 2: If the adviser is given a limited power of attorney, which limits the adviser to trading the account so that funds cannot be withdrawn, then this is not considered to be taking custody.) Inadvertent Payments Not Considered to Be "Custody" if Returned Within 3 Days NASAA has amended its rules regarding custody. It defines "custody" not only as holding customer funds or securities but also as the ability to appropriate them or to obtain possession of them. If a client inadvertently gives securities or funds to an investment adviser, as long as they are returned within 3 business days, then the adviser has NOT taken custody. If an adviser inadvertently receives a check from a customer made out to a third party (for example, the customer mistakenly puts a check made out to another payee in the adviser's envelope), as long as the adviser mails the check to the third party within 3 business days of receipt, then the adviser has NOT taken custody. Annual ADV Update - 90 Days of Fiscal Year End NASAA requires that each investment advisory firm file an update of its Form ADV registration in the State within 90 days of fiscal year end - already covered in the text. (Note, that the SEC rule for Federal covered advisers is the same.) Material Change ADV Update - 30 Days If there is a significant material event, an "other-than-annual" amendment must be filed in the State within 30 days under NASAA rules - already covered in the text. (Note, in contrast, that the SEC rule for Federal covered advisers requires these to be made "promptly.")
Conduct of Customer Account Rules 4 Critical Pieces of Information to Open Account When opening a new account for a customer, 4 critical pieces of information must be obtained: Customer Name, Address, Date of Birth; and Social Security Number Failure to get each of the 4 pieces of information is a violation. This information must be used to independently verify the customer's identity promptly after account opening. If Margin Account, Get Customer Signature Promptly After Account Opening There is no requirement for a customer signature on the new account form when opening a cash account for a client; but it is required when a margin account is opened. The customer must sign the margin agreement "promptly" after the first trade under NASAA rules. By signing the margin agreement, the customer pledges the securities in the account as collateral for the loan. Agent Must Sign New Account Form, Manager Must Sign When opening an account (cash or margin), the agent must sign the new account form (this is the agent's attestation that the information is true as given by the customer); and the manager must sign the new account form, accepting the account for the firm. No Unauthorized Trading of Customer Account When a customer opens an account, only that customer is authorized to place trades (or any one of the customers in a joint account can place trades). Trades from customers can be accepted verbally or in writing. Unauthorized trading of a customer account is a prohibited practice. Joint Accounts Regarding joint accounts, a trade can be placed by any one of the account owners; and any one of the account owners can demand that a check be drawn. However, any check drawn on a joint account must be made out to the "full account name" - not to the name of a single tenant.
Third Party Cannot Place Trade Unless Given Written Authorization A "third party" is prohibited from placing a trade in a customer account unless the customer gave the third party a power of attorney in writing. Note that if an individual is a customer's attorney (like a family lawyer), that person does not have a power of attorney to trade the customer's account (unless the customer gives written authorization). Discretionary Accounts An agent or investment adviser representative cannot exercise discretion in a customer's account without written customer authorization. NASAA Rule for Investment Advisers Under NASAA rules for investment advisers, written authority to exercise discretion must be obtained from the customer no later than 10 business days after being given verbal discretionary authority by that customer. This rule does not apply to broker-dealers - in this case, the SEC rule prevails. SEC Rule for Broker-Dealers Under SEC rules for broker-dealers, written customer authority is required prior to accepting any discretionary orders (remember, Federal law will prevail over State law; if there is no Federal law, the State law applies). Trade Is Not Discretionary if Agent Only Selects Price and/or Time of Execution Also, note that a trade is only considered to be discretionary if the representative selects the size of the trade or the security to be purchased; it is not considered to be discretionary if the representative only selects the price and time of execution. Broker-Dealer "Suitability" Standard Before recommending a security to a customer, the agent of a broker-dealer must first determine that the investment is "suitable" for the customer, based on the customer's investment objectives, needs, risk tolerance and investment time horizon. A brokerdealer that owns a security may sell it to one of its customers, as long as the security is suitable (this would be the case if the broker-dealer were a market maker in the security). Actions that violate the "suitability rule" include: Failure to inquire as to a customer's financial situation, needs, and investment objective. Recommending securities without regard to the customer's financial situation or objective. Recommending a security without having a reasonable basis for the recommendation. Churning customer accounts (performing trades of excessive frequency). Performing excessively large trades in customer accounts. Failure to sufficiently describe important facts and risks concerning a transaction. Making blanket recommendations of the same security to all customers. Investment Adviser "Fiduciary" Standard The suitability standard used for broker-dealers does NOT apply to investment advisers. Rather, investment advisers are fiduciaries, and cannot take the opposite side to a trade. The basic idea is that if an investment is good for the customer, why would an investment adviser that owns it want to sell? If an investment adviser recommends a security to a customer, the investment adviser can (and should) buy that same security for its personal account. It cannot sell that security to the customer. Thus, investment advisers should be investing alongside their customers.
Payment, Margin, and Commingling Rules Regulation T Applies to Both Cash and Margin Accounts Regulation T of the Federal Reserve Board sets margin requirements for non-exempt securities. Regulation T covers both cash accounts and margin accounts. Long Sale In a cash account, the customer pays in full. The customer can sell securities that they own (a "long" sale because the customer owns (is long) the stock). Short Sale In a margin account, the customer puts up the Regulation T requirement (50% for stocks) and is loaned the other 50% by the broker-dealer. In a margin account, securities can be sold "long" and they can be sold "short" - which is the sale of borrowed shares. Prompt Payment for Purchases When a customer buys securities, payment must be obtained "promptly," but no later than 2 business days past settlement date. If payment is not received, the unpaid securities position must be sold out and the account is frozen for 90 days. Frozen Account A "frozen" account does not mean that the customer can't trade the account. Many firms call it putting a "CUF" on the account (Cash Up Front) because, in a frozen account, the customer no longer is expected to pay promptly - rather, the customer must have the cash on deposit at the broker to buy securities before the trade is entered. If the customer behaves for 90 days, the freeze comes off the account and the customer is back to paying "promptly" for securities purchases. Cash/Securities Must Be Delivered on Settlement In a cash or margin account, a customer cannot make a purchase without intending to pay by settlement. In a cash account, a customer cannot sell long unless they intend to deliver the security on settlement. In a margin account, a customer cannot sell short unless the securities to be borrowed are "located" (and this must be documented) and can be delivered on settlement. Cannot Extend Loan Amount Greater Than Limit Set by Regulation T Lending money to a customer in contravention of Regulation T requirements is prohibited. For example, if the Regulation T requirement is 75% (this is the margin to buy LEAP (long term) options), then the "loan value" of the security is 25%. Thus, the maximum loan that can be extended to a customer on this security is 25% of current market value. Any loan percentage that is greater than this violates Regulation T Street Name Securities As part of the margin agreement, a broker-dealer is permitted to place customer securities into "street name" - that is, the securities are kept in the name of the brokerdealer, not the customer. Therefore, if the customer does not pay off the loan when demanded, the broker-dealer can simply sell out the securities without needing a customer signature. Commingling Rules As part of the margin agreement, the broker-dealer is permitted to commingle (mixup) one customer's street name margin securities with those of other customers, and can pledge them to a bank to get a loan to the broker. This loan to the broker funds the loan that the broker made to the customer. The rules on commingling are: A broker-dealer can commingle one customer's margin securities with those of other customers; A broker-dealer cannot commingle proprietary positions (securities owned by the firm) with customer securities positions; An agent of a broker-dealer cannot commingle proprietary positions (securities owned by the firm) with customer securities positions; An agent of a broker-dealer cannot take customer funds or securities and keep them personally. The commingling rules also apply to investment advisers and IARs. Customer Request to Transfer and Ship Securities When a customer buys securities, the firm can either hold them in street name (margin account) or registered in customer name (in a cash account). If the customer wishes the securities purchased to be "transferred and shipped," this means that the customer actually wants the physical certificates sent to them (presumably so they can be kept safely under that customer's mattress). In this case, the securities are transferred from street name into the customer's name and are actually sent to the customer at their address. In order for securities to be transferred and shipped, they must be fully paid. Thus, securities held in a margin account cannot be transferred and shipped unless the loan (called the customer debit) is paid off first.
Orders and Confirmations Broker-Dealer Order Ticket Information An order for a customer cannot be entered by a broker-dealer without the order ticket having the following information: Customer name or account number; Agent (registered representative) name or number; Buy or Sell; If sale - Long or Short; Whether order was "Solicited" or "Unsolicited"; Number of shares or bonds to be traded; Description of security to be traded; and Execution price (if the order is a market order, there is no price - only the designation "MKT"). Note that there is no requirement for customer address, date of birth or social security number on an order ticket. Solicited or Unsolicited Each order ticket must be marked as either a solicited transaction or an unsolicited transaction. This is required because "suitability" complaints have no standing when a trade is unsolicited. Order Ticket Time Stamps SEC rules require that order tickets be time-stamped with the following: Time of order receipt; Time of order execution; Time of order cancellation, if canceled. By requiring these time stamps, front running violations can be easily detected by regulators. In addition, if there is an error in execution, having the time stamp record allows the firm to more easily trace the cause of the error. NASAA Rule for Investment Adviser Order Tickets NASAA has a rule for order ticket information that must be retained by Investment Advisers, and of course, it is different than the SEC rules for broker-dealers. Because an IA sends an order to a broker-dealer for execution, the IA must keep a record of the order as sent - there is no requirement for the IA to keep the record of the actual execution - this would be kept by the broker-dealer that filled the order. The NASAA rule states that Investment Adviser order tickets must contain: Name of the person at the IA who recommended the transaction; Name of the person who placed the order; Date of order entry; Name of account for which order was entered; Name of broker-dealer or bank to which the order was sent for execution; Whether the order was discretionary. The "Do It" Rule An order placed by a customer must be filled according to the customer's instructions. If a broker-dealer or investment adviser receives an order from a customer that it believes to be unsuitable, the customer must be told this, and if the customer directs that the trade be done - Do It! In this theme, if a customer directs that a trade be done in a specific market, then follow the customer's instructions. If a customer directs that a specific percentage of their portfolio be invested in a specific stock - Do It! Also note that if a customer directs, you still cannot do anything that is prohibited. For example, if a customer directs that a trade of a listed security be executed privately and not in the public market, this is not permitted. Not Following Instructions Also note that NASAA states that deliberately failing to follow a customer's instructions is a prohibited practice - so the "Do It!" rule prevails. Limit Order Display Rule The SEC has another rule called the "limit order display rule." This rule requires that market makers in securities that receive customer limit orders that are better priced than their "displayed quote" must show the better priced quote in the market. The market maker cannot bury the customer order! For example, assume that a market maker has a displayed quote in the market for ABC stock of: Bid Ask 15.00 (400 shares) 15.50 (300 shares) The market maker currently is willing to Buy 400 shares of the stock at $15.00 (the Bid); and is willing to sell 300 shares of the stock at $15.50 (the Ask). If the market maker receives a customer limit order to: Buy 200 shares of ABC at $15.20, it must update its Bid (Buy) to reflect the order since it is better priced. The updated quote from the market maker that will show in the market is: Bid Ask 15.20 (200 shares) 15.50 (300 shares) If the market maker now receives a customer limit order to: Sell 600 shares of ABC at $15.40, it must update its Ask (Sell) to reflect the order since it is better priced. The updated quote from the market maker that will show in the market is: Bid Ask 15.20 (200 shares) 15.40 (600 shares) (Also note that as exchanges have improved the computer technology by adopting electronic order books that can hold each customer order individually, this rule really now only applies to Pink OTC Markets quotes, where market makers still only show 1 quote.)
Confirmation Information After a trade is executed, the customer must be sent a confirmation detailing the specifics of the executed trade. The exchange where the trade was effected used to be required to be disclosed on the confirm, but this is no longer the case because all markets are linked and trades must be done at the best price in a given market or routed to the better-priced market for execution. The information that must be disclosed on the confirmation includes: Broker-dealer name, address and telephone number; Customer name and address; Number of shares bought or sold; Security description; Execution price; Commission charge for an agency trade; Whether a payment for order flow was received. No Disclosure if Trade Was Solicited on Confirm Note that there is no requirement to disclose whether the trade was solicited or not on the confirm - this is only required on the order ticket copy. Disclosure if Payment for Order Flow Was Received on Confirm Regarding payment for order flow, the SEC permits market makers and exchanges to pay order entry firms for routing their orders to them. In essence, the market maker is "giving up" part of his spread (difference between bid and ask quote) to the order entry firm. The SEC permits this because it believes that this allows order entry firms to reduce their commission costs to customers (Now you know how discount brokers can charge $8 per trade and make money - they get payments for order flow as well!). However, if a payment for order flow was accepted, this must be disclosed on the customer confirmation.
Chapter 3: Business Practices Borrowing, Lending, Sharing, or Guaranteeing - Customer Accounts Borrowing, Lending, Sharing, or Guaranteeing Borrowing, Lending, Sharing, or Guaranteeing Borrowing from Customer A broker-dealer is prohibited from borrowing money or securities from customer accounts. Note, however, that a broker-dealer is permitted to borrow a customer's securities if the customer gives written permission by signing a loan consent agreement. An agent of a broker-dealer or an investment adviser representative cannot borrow money from a customer personally. An exception is granted if the "customer" is a lending institution that is lending to the agent or investment adviser representative on the same terms (not better terms) as it would extend to any other customer. For example, if an IAR has a customer that is a savings and loan, the IAR can get a mortgage on a home purchase from that savings and loan as long as it is on the same terms as the S&L offers its other customers. If an agent of a broker-dealer has a customer that is a relative, NASAA has a very different rule than FINRA. FINRA allows registered representatives to borrow from relatives that are customers; NASAA does not! (Since this is NASAA's test, you must know their rule!) Lending to a Customer by Agents, IAs And IARs Is Prohibited Lending money or securities personally to a customer is prohibited. This rule applies to both agents and investment adviser representatives. In addition, investment advisers (IA firms) cannot lend money to customers. Broker-Dealers and Banks Can Lend Note, however, that a broker-dealer or bank can lend money to a customer using securities as collateral under the provisions of Regulation T of the Federal Reserve Board. Agent Cannot Share in Gain or Loss of Customer Account Unless Joint Account Is Opened with Customer Sharing in the gains and losses in a customer's account is prohibited. However, an agent of a broker-dealer is permitted to share in the gain and loss of a customer account as long as: A joint account is opened with the customer; Sharing is in proportion to capital contributed; and Manager approval is obtained. An agent will often offer to open a joint account with a customer in such a manner, because then the customer knows that the agent is not likely to make bad recommendations, since the agent will lose as well. Such an account "aligns the agent's and customer's interests." Investment Adviser Cannot Share and Cannot Open Joint Account with Customer The sharing rule is different for investment adviser accounts. Investment advisers and investment adviser representatives are outright prohibited from sharing in customer accounts - they cannot open joint accounts with customers. Because IAs and IARs are held to a fiduciary standard, while broker-dealers and agents are not, if they make personal investments, IAs and IARs must invest "alongside the customer" - that is, make the same personal investments as they are recommending to customers. Thus, they will experience the same gain and loss personally as their customers anyway! Cannot Guarantee a Customer Account Against Loss Finally, guaranteeing a customer account against loss by either a broker-dealer, agent, investment adviser, or investment adviser representative is prohibited. This applies to both exempt and non-exempt securities.
Charges to Customers Broker-Dealer Commission Charges Must Be "Fair and Reasonable" Commission charges to customers imposed by broker-dealers must be "fair and reasonable." A customer cannot agree to pay a higher commission unless it is justified by extra "value" being offered by the agent or broker-dealer. For example, a broker-dealer that gives lots of hand holding, gives proprietary research, has great stock picks, etc., can charge a higher commission than a "bare-bones" discount broker that just does trade executions. An agent cannot charge a higher commission rate based on the subsequent performance of recommendations. Commission Disclosed Only on Confirmation Any commission charge is not required to be disclosed at the time the trade is placed. The only requirement is that it must be disclosed in writing on the trade confirmation. Disclosure of Unusual Costs and Fees Because the customer normally does not know the commission charge until they get the confirmation, to avoid "unpleasant surprises," NASAA requires that any unusual fees or costs for a trade be disclosed verbally at the time the trade is placed. For example, if a customer wants to buy an "odd lot" (less than 100 shares), the commission charge is usually much higher than normal, and this must be disclosed to the customer in advance. Broker-Dealers Can Charge for Clerical Services But Not for Recommendations Also note that broker-dealers can charge for clerical services, such as safekeeping of securities and appraisals of securities. However, they cannot charge for recommendations of securities - if they do, they become "statutory" investment advisers that must register as such and that are subject to all of the investment adviser rules. Investment Advisers Cannot Charge Excessive Fees For investment advisers, NASAA states that charging an excessive advisory fee to a customer is a prohibited practice. Fees for services rendered must be comparable to other investment advisers who operate in similar situations. Failing to Disclose the Availability of Discounts to All Customers Failing to disclose to all customers the availability of fee discounts. Fee discounts cannot be made available on a "selective" basis to customers. If a discount is offered to given customers, any other customers that meet the qualifications for that discount must be given the discounted rate. The availability of discounts must be disclosed in the adviser's brochure (Form ADV Part 2A).
Prohibited Statements to Customers
The list of prohibited statements to customers is extensive. The basic idea is that one must be ethical and not lie to, or mislead, customers. Misleading or Untrue Statements Misleading or untrue statements are prohibited, such as: Inaccurate market quotations. Incorrect statements of an issuer's past earnings or future earnings projections. Inaccurate statements as to the amount of commission or mark-up charged in a securities transaction. Advising a customer that an exchange listing is anticipated for a security, without knowing whether the statement is true. Telling a customer that registration of the security means that either the SEC or the State "approves" of that security. Telling a customer that a mutual fund is "no-load" when it charges 12b-1 fees in excess of .25% annually. 12b-1 fees are charges against net assets that a mutual fund can charge for the cost of soliciting new investment to the fund. (FINRA has a rule that states that a mutual fund cannot be called no load if its 12b-1 fees exceed this limit; it also sets a maximum 1% annual 12b-1 fee for any fund.) Telling a customer that registration of an agent means that either the SEC or the State Administrator "approves" of that agent. Promising to perform services for a customer without any intent or ability to do such. Making exaggerated claims about investment performance. Misrepresenting the status of a customer's account. Telling a customer that registration as an adviser means that the State Administrator "approves" of the firm or "endorses" the firm (note however, that investment advisers are permitted to call themselves "investment counsels," as long as this is the principal business of the firm - otherwise they cannot do so). Telling a customer that an asset allocation program is "proven and tested," when in fact, no one has ever used the program. Omissions of Material Fact Omissions of material fact are a violation under the Act. Examples are: Deliberately being selective in the information which is given to a customer. Failure to inform a customer that a transaction will incur larger than normal commission, tax, or transaction costs (note that there is no requirement to disclose normal commission charges to a customer prior to executing a securities transaction, but all commissions must always be disclosed on customer trade confirmations). Failure to bring customers' written complaints to the attention of the brokerdealer. SEC and NASAA rules require that original copies of all written complaints with their resolution be retained as a required record.
Giving the customer a research recommendation prepared by someone other than that firm, without disclosing that fact (this is called "Third Party Research"). Failure to tell a mutual fund customer about breakpoints. A breakpoint is a sales charge reduction based on the dollar amount invested in a mutual fund. The customer must be made aware of the dollar threshold for the sales charge reduction and also must be made aware of a letter of intent (LOI) feature, if offered by the fund. The LOI gives the customer up to 13 months to complete the breakpoint if the letter is signed. Also prohibited are the following: Soliciting Orders for Unregistered Non-exempt Securities For example, soliciting a customer to buy unregistered common stock is prohibited; soliciting a customer to buy unregistered municipal bonds is permitted (since these are exempt securities). Recommending Stock of Publicly Traded Parent Company For example, an agent at Merrill Lynch cannot recommend the purchase of Bank of America stock (which owns Merrill Lynch) unless this is disclosed verbally at the time of the recommendation; and in writing on the confirmation.
Customer Complaints, Mail, Incapacitation, or Death A customer complaint is defined as one received in writing (email counts here). A customer calling up and yelling is not a complaint. If a written complaint is received by an agent or an IAR, it must be given to a manager for resolution. If a customer sends a written complaint and then changes his mind about the complaint and asks for it back, the original written complaint must be retained as a record and a copy returned to the client. Any mail that the firm sends to a customer, such as confirmations and account statements, must be sent to the customer at the mailing address provided by the customer (email is OK). Customer mail cannot be suppressed; and cannot be directed to be sent to a branch office or a P.O. box designated by an agent. The "idea" is that the customer must know what is going on in their account. There have been many frauds, especially with elderly customers, where an agent who had discretion over the account, churned it to generate commissions, and directed that the customer mail be sent to a different address, so the customer did not know what was going on until it was too late! Death of a Customer If a broker-dealer or adviser is notified that a customer has died, the firm must: cancel all open orders; note the date of death on the account; freeze the account from removal of assets; and wait for the proper paperwork (copy of the death certificate, last will and testament, and probate court filings, if required) needed to transfer the account or assets to an executor or beneficiary. Any Power of Attorney Ceases Upon Customer Death, Durable Power Stays In Force if Customer Is Mentally Incapacitated If the account had a power of attorney, that "died" with the customer and is now invalid. Also note that a "so-called" durable power of attorney also dies with the customer - the only distinction is that if a customer is incapacitated, the durable power of attorney remains in effect. If the account has a "non-durable" power of attorney, the authorization expires upon the customer's incapacitation (most powers of attorney are "durable").
Trading Practices Inside Information, Cannot Trade Based on Inside Information Inside information is defined as information about an issuer that has not been made public. "Material" inside information is information that is not public that would have an effect on the value of the issuer's securities in the marketplace. The Act prohibits persons from: effecting securities transactions based on material inside information. making recommendations to either buy or sell based on material inside information. Tipper-Tippee The Act prohibits persons from transmitting material inside information to someone else, who might trade based on that information (the so-called "tipper-tippee" doctrine, that holds not only the person who traded as liable; but also holds liable the person that gave the tip that resulted in the trade). Note that the "tipper" is not held liable if the information that results in the trade is accidentally or unintentionally transmitted to the "tippee." Also note that there is no violation for either the tipper or tippee if no trade results from the transmittal of the inside information. Broker-Dealers Must Have Procedures to Prevent Misuse of Material Non-public Information Federal insider trading law requires broker-dealers to establish, maintain, and enforce written policies and procedures designed to prevent the misuse of material, non-public information by any associated person. In particular, this legislation was aimed at investment bankers engaged in takeovers. Large broker-dealers have divisions for investment banking; mergers and acquisitions; trading; and retail. Inside information is routinely received through investment banking and merger activities. It is not a violation to receive inside information. It is a violation to use the information to trade for profit. For example, if a broker-dealer is hired to advise on the potential takeover of a publicly traded company, investment bankers at the firm who work on the deal possess inside information about the potential takeover. If an investment banker at the firm buys the stock of the target company personally, the investment banker has violated the insider trading laws. For example, if a broker-dealer's research department is about to come out with a favorable research report on a publicly traded stock and a financial adviser at the firm gets an advance copy of the report and buys the stock personally based on the report, the financial adviser has violated the insider trading laws.
If Agent Receives Inside Information, Report to Regulator If "inside information" of a material nature is received by an agent, it must be reported to the exchange where the security trades (via that firm's compliance department). Inducing Trading Based on Rumors Is Prohibited Inducing customers to trade based on hearsay or rumor is also prohibited. While this is not "inside information" because the truth of the information is not known, it is a violation to use rumors to generate customer trades. Front Running Is Prohibited If a broker-dealer or adviser receives a large customer trade order that is likely to influence the price of the security, the firm cannot "front run" that trade - that is, place an order for its own account ahead of the placing that customer's order. Manipulation Is Prohibited Participating in manipulative market activities such as giving fictitious quotes; effecting "wash trades" and "matched orders" (these are not free market trades, but rather these are trades between co-conspirators who are attempting to make it look like there is trading in the stock at even higher or lower prices) is a prohibited practice.
Painting the Tape Participating in transactions only to give the appearance of trading activity in the security, also known as "painting the tape," is a prohibited practice. Trading Ahead of Underwriting or Research Is Prohibited A broker-dealer that has a research or underwriting department cannot "trade" its own account based on information that is received from either of these departments. For example, an underwriter that is advising on a takeover deal cannot "tip-off" the firm's trading desk about the impending offer, since this is likely to raise the market price of the stock and the firm's trading desk could profit from this. This is a type of inside information. For example, a research department that is about to release a favorable research report on a company cannot "tip-off" the firm's trading desk about the report, since this is likely to raise the market price of the stock and the firm's trading desk could profit from this. This is a type of inside information.
New Issue Rules and Research Rules Failure to Deliver a Prospectus When Selling a New Issue Selling a non-exempt new issue security to a customer without providing a final prospectus to the customer, at or prior to confirmation of sale, is a prohibited practice. For example, a new issue of common stock cannot be sold to a customer without delivering a prospectus. A new issue of municipal bonds can be delivered to a customer without a prospectus delivery because the securities are exempt. Marking-Up or Highlighting a Prospectus Marking up or highlighting a prospectus delivered in connection with the sale of a new issue is prohibited. Doing so alters the legal content of the prospectus and is therefore prohibited. Third Party Research Disclosure If a broker-dealer or investment adviser prepares a research report, it can be distributed to customers with no special disclosures other than the standard "conflict of interest" disclosures that any research report must contain. If a broker-dealer or investment adviser buys or uses "third party research" (this is research prepared by another firm) and distributes it to customers, the fact that it was prepared by an outside firm must be disclosed. IPO Allocations to Broker-Dealers and Their Employees Are Prohibited It is very common in a common stock Initial Public Offering (IPO) that the underwriter prices the issue a "bit low" to make sure that the issue is sold out to investors. This creates a conflict, because industry insiders know this and want to buy the issue from the underwriters (since it is likely to trade higher once it opens for trading in the market). It is unethical for employees of broker-dealers to buy IPOs from underwriters. Free Riding and Withholding This is a prohibited practice called "free riding and withholding" - which is withholding an IPO from sale to the public by a broker-dealer or associated person, with the intention of keeping it personally so that a "free ride" can be taken on the issue's price rise when it opens for trading. IPO allocations can be made to employees and officers of the issuer, the issuer's suppliers, and the general public. They cannot be made to broker-dealers, brokerdealer officers and broker-dealer employees. IPO Allocations to Investment Advisers Are Permitted IPO allocations can be made to investment advisers, but the adviser must buy the allocation for all of its clients - it cannot keep the allocation for the IA's account or an IAR's personal account. Underwriting Manager Cannot Issue Research Report on Issue for Prescribed Time Windows A member firm that acted as a manager or co-manager in an underwriting of that issuer's securities cannot issue a research report on that company for 10 days following the effective date for an initial public offering; and 3 days following the effective date for a secondary offering.
Communications Rules
Broker-dealer advertising comes under FINRA rules and Federal covered adviser advertising comes under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 rules. State-registered investment adviser advertising comes under NASAA rules (which parallel the Advisers Act rules). NASAA Investment Adviser Advertising Rule NASAA requires that State-registered adviser advertising: cannot contain a testimonial (in contrast federal law - FINRA for broker-dealers and SEC for federal covered investment advisers - permits testimonials in advertising as long as it is disclosed prominently if the maker is paid and if the maker is a client); cannot state that any report of research will be provided for free unless this is offered without condition; cannot contain false, untrue or misleading statements; can include a list of recommendations made with their performance as long as all recommendations over that period (1 year minimum) are included, along with the market price at the time of the recommendation and the current market price of the security. The list cannot be deliberately selective. The use of the internet by Broker-Dealers, representatives (BD Agents), Investment Advisers and Investment Adviser representatives (IARs) has created an issue for the State Administrators. The question raised with an advertisement placed on the internet, which can be accessed in any State, becomes: "Is the internet communication an offering of securities or advisory services in that State, hence registration is required?" Internet Communications by BDs, IAs and Their Agents NASAA has issued the following interpretation for broker-dealers (BDs), investment advisers (IAs) and their agents. An "Internet Communication" shall NOT be deemed to be "transacting business" in the State where the communication was received if: The communication is limited to general information on products and services and does not involve effecting securities transactions, attempting to effect securities transactions, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation; The communication contains a legend that the Broker-Dealer, Investment Adviser, BD Agent or IARs may only transact business in that State if first registered in that State; or if that "person" is excluded or exempted from registration; Any follow-up individualized responses to persons that involve effecting securities transactions or the attempt to effect securities transactions; or the rendering of investment advice for compensation; cannot be made unless that "person" has complied with the State's registration requirements (or is exempted or excluded); and The Internet Communication contains a "fire wall" or other procedure designed to ensure compliance with the above requirements. BD Agent/IAR Internet Communications For Internet Communications by BD Agents or IARs only, the communication shall NOT be deemed to be "transacting business" in the State where it was received if: The Internet Communication must prominently disclose the affiliation of the BD Agent or Investment Adviser Representative with the Broker-Dealer or Investment Adviser; The Broker-Dealer or Investment Adviser retains responsibility for reviewing and approving the content of any Internet Communication by any Agent and authorizes the distribution of information on the particular products and services offered through the Internet Communication; and The Agent cannot exceed the scope of authority granted by the Broker-Dealer or Investment Adviser in the Internet Communication. Of course all of the Uniform Securities Act rules, such as filing of advertising if requested by the Administrator, still apply to Internet Communications. Note that if the Internet Communication does not adhere to these limits, then the Broker-Dealer, Investment Adviser, and their agents would be required to register in each State where a customer accesses the Web site! Filing Rules Also note that, if Internet Communications are required to be filed in a State, the State can require the filing not just of a web page that is accessed by customers, but can also require the filing of the entire Web site. In addition, if any updates are made to the Web site, the old version must be archived and be available for inspection or filing. The State usually requires such a filing in printed (not electronic) form - but either form can be requested by the State. Another issue arises because of the internet. Customers cannot be solicited to trade securities or to buy advisory services via email solicitations unless the Broker-Dealer, BD Agent, Investment Adviser and Investment Adviser Representative (IAR) are registered in the State where the customer resides. For example, a BD Agent located and registered in the State of New York cannot send out an email to potential clients in the State of California recommending specific securities unless the BD Agent is registered in the State of California. Cannot Email "Spam" Recommendations of Securities Because "spam" email recommendations of securities do not involve interaction with customers, so that the suitability of such a recommendation can be determined for that customer, this is an "unethical business practice" and is an inappropriate activity for a Broker-Dealer, BD Agent, Investment Adviser, or Investment Adviser Representative (IAR). Cannot Solicit Business or Make Recommendations in Internet Chat Rooms Another issue is the participation of BD Agents or Investment Adviser Representatives in internet "chat" rooms about investing. Participation in such chat rooms is not, by itself, prohibited. However, the participation of the BD Agent or IAR must be limited to making general statements about investing. The making of specific recommendations in a chat room is prohibited (since the suitability of each recipient cannot be determined); and the giving of an opinion in a chat room as a means of soliciting business is prohibited as well (because the Agent or Representative must be registered in each State where a prospect receives the solicitation).
Social Media NASAA is concerned about fraudsters using social media to promote investment schemes. Through social media, fraudsters can spread false or misleading information about a stock to large numbers of people at low cost and effort. They can conceal their true identities by acting anonymously or even impersonating credible sources of market information by creating a web page that uses a company’s logo, links to the company’s actual website, or that references an actual person who works for the company. Red Flags Red flags to watch out for include: Limited history of posts: Be skeptical of information from social media accounts that lack a prior history of posts or messages. Pressure to buy or sell NOW: A stock should be researched before making an investment decision. Unsolicited investment information: Fraudsters looks for victims on social media sites, chat rooms and bulletin boards. Be wary of communications from a sender not personally known that solicit an investment or that provide information about a particular stock. Unlicensed sellers: Make sure that the person offering investments is properly licensed by searching BrokerCheck (agents) and the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) website. Affinity fraud: Investment scams often prey on members of identifiable groups - religious, elderly, professional, etc. The person who makes the contact may even have been fooled into believing that the investment is legitimate, when it is not. Common Scams Common scams using social media are: Pump and Dump: False claims are made about a thinly-traded stock on social media such as Facebook and Twitter to push the stock price up. Before starting the scheme, the fraudsters buy the stock. When the stock price is pumped up, the fraudsters sell their positions, hence the term “pump and dump.” Research “Opinions” and Online Investment Newsletters: Fraudulent promoters claim to offer independent, unbiased opinions, usually of penny stocks. They can be paid by the company to do this (which is not illegal as long as the payment and relationship with the company is disclosed). However, fraudsters do not make this required disclosure and are usually attempting to push the stock price up, so insiders and favored investors can sell at a profit. High Yield Investment Programs (HYIPs): Unregistered investments sold by unlicensed individuals promising incredible returns, often of 1-2% per day, at little or no risk. Fraudsters use social media to promote HYIP websites, offering “lucrative” returns and “guaranteed profits”, and encourage their followers to use a referral link to share the HYIP website with others, in return for a referral fee.
Agent or Investment Adviser Representative Rules
Prohibited Actions Before Being Registered as an Agent in a State An individual that is not properly licensed in a State as an agent cannot solicit securities business in the State. This includes making recommendations, soliciting securities trades, performing a suitability determination and writing order tickets. Permitted Actions Before Being Registered as an Agent in a State Prior to being licensed in a State, an individual can only perform clerical or ministerial functions. Falling under this definition are taking new account information, entering customer orders that have already been taken by a licensed individual, reporting completed trades and responding to customer account inquiries. If Agent Takes Outside Work - Notify Firm If an agent of a broker-dealer wants to take any outside work, they must give notice to the firm and follow instructions of the firm. Private Securities Transactions Trading "privately" with a customer is prohibited. These trades have not been recorded on the books of the broker-dealer. If an agent effects such a "private" transaction, then that agent becomes a statutory "broker-dealer" who should have been registered with the State. Selling Away This is commonly known as "selling away," because the agent is "selling away" from theirbroker-dealer. Also note that if the agent received written permission of their broker-dealer to effect this transaction; and if the broker-dealer recorded the transaction on its books and supervised it, then this would have been permitted. No Sharing Commissions with Unlicensed Person Sharing in commissions with unlicensed individuals for securities-based business is prohibited. Unlicensed individuals cannot earn commissions or any other sales incentive-based compensation. No Sharing Commissions with Person Licensed at Another Firm Note that sharing commissions with other individuals holding securities licenses is perfectly legal - as long as both individuals are registered through the same brokerdealer; or broker-dealers that are under common control.
Note that sharing in commissions between two registered individuals who are at two different broker-dealers is prohibited. Investment Advisers Can Pay Referral Fees, Solicitor Who Receives Fee Must Be Licensed in the State Note: Do not confuse the prohibition on sharing commissions with the payment of referral fees. Agents of broker-dealers are subject to the prohibition on sharing commissions with unlicensed persons or with agents registered through other brokerdealers. On the other hand, investment advisers do not earn commissions and are not subject to this rule. They are permitted to pay referral fees to solicitors; however, the State requires that the solicitor be registered in the State as an adviser representative to accept the fee. Investment Adviser Can Send Trades to BD Affiliate with Client Consent Finally, an investment adviser can send its portfolio trades to an affiliated brokerdealer, and that affiliated broker-dealer can earn commissions on those trades, as long as this is disclosed to customers and they give written consent (this is typically part of the advisory agreement).
Uniform Prudent Investor Act
Modern Portfolio Theory Guides Investments This Act, adopted in most States, is a modernization of the "prudent investor rule" restricting the investment authority of fiduciaries. Instead of setting forth a list of "approved" securities for investment, the Prudent Investor Act allows fiduciaries to use modern portfolio theory for investment decision-making. Investment Performance Based on Overall Portfolio Return Thus, instead of just investing in securities that have minimal risk, the fiduciary can apply risk-return analysis to choose the "best" investments for the level of risk assumed. Investment performance is not measured on each individual investment, but rather by looking at the overall portfolio return. To be considered when setting overall investment strategy are: General economic conditions; Effect of inflation or deflation; Tax consequences; The role that each investment plays as part of the overall portfolio; Expected total return; Other resources of beneficiaries; Need for liquidity, income and preservation or appreciation of capital; An asset's special value to one or more of the beneficiaries. Asset Diversification, Manage Impartially if Multiple Beneficiaries The trustee must diversify the trust assets, unless there are special circumstances that obviate this requirement. All assets must be managed solely for the benefit of the beneficiaries; and if the trust has 2 or more beneficiaries, the trust must be managed impartially, taking into account the differing interests of the beneficiaries. Also, the trustee must seek to minimize costs associated with managing trust assets. Trustee Can Appoint Investment Manager Finally, fiduciaries, who usually cannot give a third party trading authorization, are permitted to delegate investment decisions to qualified agents - so the trustee can sign a contract with an investment adviser. This Act has been adopted in most States.
Rules for External Threats Money Laundering Rules Apply to Broker-Dealers and Investment Advisers Money laundering is the conversion of illegally obtained funds into apparently legitimate money. Originally, money laundering regulations were targeted at illegal businesses such as drug trafficking, prostitution and gambling, where cash was used to avoid detection and also to avoid paying taxes. However, after 9/11, the laws were greatly expanded to detect and stop the flow of funds to potential terrorist groups. The original money laundering rules only applied to banks, but the PATRIOT Act passed after 9/11 extended the requirement for anti-money laundering procedures and reporting to "other financial institutions," which include broker-dealers and investment advisers. Terrorist Watch List, Foreigners Present Passport and US Tax ID Number Now, any new customer name must be matched to the "terrorist" watch list maintained by the Department of Homeland Security. Any non-US citizen who wishes to open an account must present a copy of their foreign passport and they must have obtained a US tax ID number. AML Program The money laundering regulations require financial institutions to implement an "AML" (Anti-Money Laundering) program, with procedures to detect and report money laundering activities. Required Reports The required reports include: Suspicious Activities Report ("SAR") The "SAR" must be filed with "FinCEN" (Financial Crimes Enforcement Network - part of the Department of Treasury) if there are any suspicious activities on the part of a client where the amount involved is $5,000 or more. The report must be filed within 30 days, and the client cannot be told that the report is being filed. Currency Transaction Report ("CTR"), Structurings Reported The "CTR" must be filed with FinCEN for cash deposits or withdrawals of amounts over $10,000. The report is required for "structurings" where clients break apart their transactions into amounts under $10,000 to avoid reporting. These must be aggregated over 2-week windows and reported as well. The report must be filed within 15 days, and the client cannot be told that the report is being filed. Cyber attacks on firms, usually to steal customer information and/or money, have become more common and much more sophisticated. Tech-savvy intruders can monitor, gain access to, and misappropriate customers’ confidential information
through email, laptops, smartphones, internet-connected hardware and software, flash drives, wireless communications, etc. Once access is gained to confidential client information, this can be readily translated to highly convincing identity theft schemes. Written Policies and Procedures Covering Cyber Security Firms are susceptible to these schemes and unencrypted or non-password-protected devices and email make this theft all too easy. Cyber threats also take the form of malware and phishing emails. Firms must identify and assess their own cyber risks and develop a plan to address and manage those risks. All broker-dealer and investment advisory firms must have: Specific policies and procedures, as well as related testing and verification, to defend against identity theft. Written policies and procedures to protect the security and confidentiality of customer records and information. Written policies and procedures to protect against unauthorized access to, or use of, customer records or information that could result in substantial harm or inconvenience to any customer. State-registered investment advisers come under the FTC’s "Privacy of Customer Financial Information Rule." It requires that State-registered advisers must: Information Security Program Designate an employee (or employees) to coordinate the firm’s information security program. Cyber Risk Assessment Identify reasonably foreseeable internal and external risks to the security, confidentiality, and integrity of customer information and assess the sufficiency of safeguards in place to control these risks. The risk assessment should include: Employee training and management; Information systems, including design, processing, storage, transmission, and disposal; Detecting, preventing and responding to attacks, intrusions, or other systems failures. Annual Testing Besides preventative measures, the program must address the detection of, and response to, data breaches. It also must be “comprehensive” and must be tested periodically (at least annually) and reevaluated. SEC-registered advisers come under a similar regulation imposed by FACTA - the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003. The SEC imposes the requirement on Federal-covered advisers who have the ability to direct withdrawals or transfers from client accounts to third parties. This includes advisers who have a third party power of attorney over client assets held with a qualified custodian; and advisers to private investment funds, such as hedge funds (these are known as “pooled investment vehicles”), where the adviser has the authority to direct the owner’s investment proceeds to third parties. Key points about minimizing vulnerability to cyber theft schemes are: Employee Training Employees must be trained on common cyber security risks and defensive strategies; Password Protection All employees must use and periodically change their passwords and user IDs and must be trained on safeguarding these;
Encryption Encryption software must be installed on files, emails and mobile electronic devices; Anti-virus Software Anti-virus software must be installed and updated as necessary on all electronic devices. Confirmation of Money Transfer Instructions Received Electronically Customer instructions received electronically, especially the transfer of funds outside the firm, must be authenticated with the client. This would NOT be done by return email! Your firm might use a robo-call or other confirmation service (such as a text message), or someone might have to call and confirm by voice that the client sent these instructions. NASAA states that customers should ask their investment professionals about the firm’s: Cyber preparedness; Cyber security compliance program; Cyber insurance (Is the firm insured for data breaches?); Cyber expertise; Cyber confidentiality (Does the firm use third party service providers with access to the firm’s technology systems and do they have confidentiality agreements?); Cyber incident (Has the firm had a data breach?); Cyber security safeguards (Does the firm use encryption, anti-virus and antimalware programs? Does the firm use secure email? Does the firm authenticate client instructions received electronically?). Business Continuity - Succession Planning NASAA has a Model Rule covering "Business Continuity and Succession Planning for Investment Advisers" (Broker-Dealers are already covered under a similar FINRA rule). It states that every investment adviser must establish, implement and maintain a Business Continuity Plan based on the facts and circumstances of the RIA's business model including the size of the firm, types of services provided, and number of locations of the investment adviser. The plan must provide, at a minimum, for: The protection, backup, and recovery of books and records; Alternate means of communicating with customers, key personnel, employees, vendors, service providers and regulators, including providing notice to these persons of significant business interruption, cessation of business activities or death or unavailability of key personnel; Office relocation in the event of temporary or permanent loss of a principal place of business; Assignment of duties to qualified persons in the event of death or unavailability of key personnel; and Minimizing service disruptions and client harm that could result from a significant business disruption. Internal-external Succession Plan One of the issues that must be addressed in the plan is the death or disability of key personnel. To continue servicing client accounts in such an instance, the IA can adopt either an "internal" or "external" Succession Plan. In an "internal plan," the Adviser transfers the advisory responsibilities to another IAR currently in the firm. With an "external" Succession Plan, the Adviser transfers client management to another firm.
Other Rules Allocating Block Trades Unfairly, Block Is 10,000 Shares or More An investment adviser allocating securities positions to customer accounts in a biased manner is a prohibited practice. Often, investment advisers place block trades (defined as a trade of 10,000 shares or more) which are not filled all at once. The trade execution might occur in pieces at differing prices. The adviser cannot allocate the shares purchased at the lower prices to his "best" customers. Rather, shares must be allocated across all customers participating in the block trade on a pro rata basis at the average execution price. Failing to Disclose Conflicts of Interest Not disclosing potential conflicts of interest to customers is a prohibited practice. Such conflicts of interest, that must be disclosed, and to which customers must agree to in writing include: the investment adviser receiving an advisory fee from the customer; and in addition, receiving a commission on each trade executed for the customer; the investment adviser receiving an advisory fee from the customer; and in addition the adviser receives a "referral fee" for each trade performed for that customer given to an executing broker; the investment adviser receiving so-called "soft dollar" compensation from a broker-dealer to whom the adviser directs its portfolio trades. This is very typical in the business - in return for directing trades to a specified broker-dealer, that broker-dealer gives the adviser "free" services such as research reports; real time stock quotes; etc. These arrangements are permitted as long as the "free" services directly benefit the adviser's clients; the investment adviser attending a conference where the expenses are paid by a mutual fund sponsor or other entity that offers securities. This is permitted as long as the conference is educational and not promotional and the travel and accommodation expenses are covered for the adviser only (not for the adviser's friends or family); the investment adviser allocating block trades to customer accounts using a method other than pro-rata distribution. Adviser Cannot Take a Personal Position in a Security That Is Opposite to Recommendation This list is not all inclusive. Also note that, because the adviser is a fiduciary, the adviser cannot take a securities position that is "opposite" to that recommended to a client. As a fiduciary, the adviser should always be on the same "side" of the market as the client. The basic point here is: "If an investment recommended to be purchased by the client is such a good one, why would the adviser be selling it out of the adviser's holdings to that client. Wouldn't the adviser want to own that security as well?"
Must Get Written Client Consent Prior to Settlement Therefore, the SEC rule here is more strict than simply disclosing the existence of the conflict of interest. In this case, aside from disclosing the conflict, written customer consent must be obtained prior to settlement of each such transaction. This is required if the adviser: takes securities positions in the adviser's personal account that differ from the positions being taken in client accounts; sells securities owned by the adviser to the adviser's clients. Privacy of Customer Account Information, Initial and Annual Privacy Notice, Opt-out Notice SEC Regulation S-P ("Statement of Privacy") requires broker-dealers, investment advisers and investment companies to send initial and annual privacy notices to customers outlining the firm's policies and practices on the collection and disclosure of non-public personal information to any other person. In addition, the firm must provide an "opt out" notice along with the initial notice, explaining how a customer can be excluded from any disclosures that the firm makes to others. Notices Can Be Posted on Firm's Website These notices can be delivered in writing (e.g., by mail) or electronically, if the customer agrees. The notices can also be posted on the firm's website, as long as the customer must acknowledge receipt of the notice as a step in the process of obtaining a financial product or service. The essence of the rule is that personal account information collected from an individual customer cannot be disclosed to others unless the firm details in its privacy policy the information that it might disclose to others (e.g., selling the customer's name, address and phone number to a marketing organization). In addition, the firm must permit the customer to "opt out" of any such disclosures. Essentially, Any Personal Information Collected About a Customer Falls Under the Rule The rule is very broad on this and includes information beyond the customer's financial standing. It basically includes ANY information given by a customer, including address, phone number, medical information (given to purchase security/insurance products such as variable annuities); and also includes information obtained by the institution about the customer, such as the customer's "cookie trail" through the firm's website. Note that "aggregated" information does not fall under this policy, such as a firm disclosing average customer account balances. Information that must be disclosed by the firm to a third party in order to effect a transaction for a customer, or to maintain or service a customer account, does not fall under the policy. Also, any request for information made by a court of law does not fall under the policy; nor do information requests made by regulators such as the SEC or FINRA. Promissory Note Fraud Legitimate promissory notes are marketed to sophisticated, corporate investors that have the ability to thoroughly research the company issuing the notes and determine whether the issuer will be able to repay principal and interest. However, there have been many instances of "promissory note fraud" where unlicensed individuals push bogus promissory notes that are sold as investments that offer above-market fixed interest rates and safeguarding of principal - and most of these are frauds. This is a major concern for State regulators.
Both the Salesperson and the Promissory Note Must Be Registered in the State To offer a promissory note, both the salesperson and the note must be registered in the State. Only promissory notes that have maturities of 9 months or less, that are investment grade, and that are sold in minimum increments of $50,000, are exempt from State registration. Thus, smaller note offerings (under $50,000 amount) to smaller investors are non-exempt and must be registered; and unrated note offerings or non-investment grade note offerings must also be registered in the State. Tell-tale Signs of Promissory Note Fraud The tell-tale signs of fraud in promissory note offerings are: Statements that the notes are "guaranteed" or "insured" - especially by bogus foreign entities; Promises of above-market rates of return (an above-market rate of return is not offered by a "low risk" investment, but rather by a high-risk investment); Statements that the notes are "risk-free" (these are corporate issues that have risk of default); The labeling of a start-up company's notes as "prime" (since only established companies with a history of operations and earnings can be called "prime"); and Offers of promissory notes from a stranger who does not know the customer's financial situation. Branch Location in a Bank Setting Not making required disclosures to customers that buy securities in a bank location is a prohibited practice. NASAA has a model rule for securities branches that are located within bank settings. There are FINRA member broker-dealers that specialize in marketing securities, usually mutual funds, by signing agreements with savings and loans. As part of the agreement, the member firm sets up a kiosk in each S&L branch, and licenses some of the employees of the S&L (such as tellers) to sell mutual funds. When the bank employee takes a bank customer into the kiosk, that bank employee magically transforms into a registered representative of the FINRA member firm, selling securities to the customer! If a branch is located in a bank setting where deposits are being taken: wherever possible, the physical location where the member's services are conducted should be distinct from the area where deposits are taken; the member's name shall be clearly displayed; at, or prior to, opening an account for the customer, the member must give (both orally and in writing) the "NOT-NOT-MAY" disclosure that: the account is NOT FDIC insured; securities products are NOT deposits and that they are not guaranteed by the financial institution; securities products are subject to investment risk and MAY lose value. NASAA requires the member firm to make reasonable efforts to obtain written acknowledgment of receipt of these disclosures when opening an account. Similar disclaimers are required in any communications sent to customers by the broker-dealer operating within the financial institution.
Financial Exploitation of Vulnerable Adults The purpose of the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA) Model Act to Protect Vulnerable Adults from Financial Exploitation is to empower investment advisers (IAs) and broker-dealers (BDs) to take action when senior or disabled clients are being victimized. About two-thirds of the states have enacted into law some form of the Model Act. IAs and investment adviser representatives (IARs) are shielded from administrative and civil liability when they take action to prevent a vulnerable adult from being financially exploited, as long as they do so according to the rules laid out in the Model Act. The Model Act also includes rules for when and how possible financial exploitation must be reported. The Model Act’s protections apply to vulnerable adults, also referred to as eligible adults. These include: • Anyone aged 65 or over • Anyone covered by the state’s Adult Protective Services laws This primarily means adults with a disability making them vulnerable to exploitation. Depending on the state, this may include temporary conditions such a serious illness. Note: You may wonder why minors are not protected by the Model Act. This is because states already have separate legal frameworks in place to protect minors that predate the recent push to beef up protections for adults. The Model Act defines financial exploitation to include: • Wrongfully taking, withholding, or appropriating the money, assets, or property of an eligible adult • Any act undertaken to gain control of an eligible person’s money, assets, or property through deception, intimidation, or undue influence • Any act undertaken to deprive an eligible person of the ownership, use, or benefits of their money, assets, or property through deception, intimidation, or undue influence It’s important to note two points about the broad scope of the definition of financial exploitation. First, it not only includes outright theft, but also any misuse of a vulnerable adult’s money, assets, or property. This includes merely withholding the money, assets, or property from the vulnerable adult. Additionally, the single act of converting money, assets, or property (such as liquidating an asset) for exploitative purposes is considered financial exploitation, even if the abuser has not yet taken any further action. Second, the definition of financial exploitation encompasses numerous methods of exploitation: misusing a power of attorney, guardianship, or conservatorship; threats and intimidation; deceiving the eligible adult; and any other kind of undue influence. Let’s review some specific examples of financial exploitation. While each example is different regarding what the abuser wants from the victim and how the abuser is trying to deceive the victim, they are all considered financial exploitation: • Pat’s niece has power of attorney over him. She writes checks from his account payable to herself, falsely claiming that she is reimbursing herself for expenses related to his care.
• Juan’s live-in caregiver makes him wait longer before feeding and bathing him until he agrees to give her a raise. • Amelia’s grandson comes to her home, demanding money that he says Amelia owes him. He refuses to leave until she writes him a check. • Raymond is invited to an “investment seminar for seniors” that includes a free lunch. Once there, he is subjected to high-pressure sales tactics. Raymond agrees to transfer money from his retirement account for a risky, unsuitable investment. • Jon is partially paralyzed and his only means of support is a trust fund controlled by his aunt. The trust fund could easily pay for a cleaning service for Jon’s apartment. However, his aunt withholds his rent unless Jon demonstrates “responsibility” by doing household chores that are difficult and dangerous for him. • Cathy wants her mother to sign a power of attorney giving Cathy control over her assets. Cathy does not intend to enrich herself but believes her mother can no longer manage her own affairs. Cathy comes to her mother’s home every day, demanding that her mother sign the power of attorney and refusing to leave. Ultimately, Cathy intimidates her mother into signing the power of attorney. Preventing financial exploitation is often much easier than reversing the damage or catching the perpetrators. Money and assets may be irretrievable. Transactions may have irreversible tax consequences. In cases of online fraud, families of victims often report that the authorities are unhelpful or unknowledgeable. In cases of exploitation by a relative or caregiver, the victim’s family may wait too long to report their suspicions because they trust the exploiter, don’t want to upset the victim, or are otherwise reluctant to “make accusations.” Your quick action could be the key safeguard that prevents the financial devastation of a vulnerable client. When Financial Exploitation Is Suspected When an employee of an investment adviser (IA) suspects financial exploitation, they must report it up the firm’s chain of command, according to the firm’s policies and procedures. Not every employee is considered qualified to determine whether a suspicion is reasonable; a qualified individual must make this determination. A qualified individual includes any of the following: • An investment adviser representative (IAR) • A broker-dealer (BD) agent • A person serving in a supervisory, compliance, or legal capacity within the firm Whether a qualified individual acts on a suspicion depends on whether they believe that the suspicion is reasonable. The qualified individual does not need to prove that exploitation has occurred before acting. When a qualified individual reasonably believes that a vulnerable adult is being exploited, they must promptly notify the state securities commissioner, as well as Adult Protective Services. Additionally, many states require notifying law enforcement. A qualified individual may also notify the client’s trusted third-party contact, who is a person the client has named in advance as someone the IA may contact in case of an emergency, such as suspected financial exploitation. The qualified
individual must exercise reasonable care when communicating with the third party (e.g., not disclosing confidential information unrelated to the suspected exploitation). In situations in which the trusted third party is suspected of involvement in the financial exploitation, contacting the third party is not allowed. Delay of Disbursements The Model Act allows the investment adviser (IA) or broker-dealer (BD) to delay disbursing funds from an account if the disbursement is reasonably believed to be an attempt at financial exploitation. If the IA or BD delays disbursement, they must complete these follow-up steps: • Notify every person authorized to transact on the account in writing within 2 business days. An exception is notifying anyone suspected of involvement in the financial exploitation; they must not be notified. • Notify Adult Protective Services and the state securities commissioner within 2 business days. • Conduct an internal review of the situation, including any new information learned after holding the disbursement. Report the results of this internal review to Adult Protective Services and the state securities commissioner within 7 business days. By default, a disbursement delay lasts for 15 business days. Several factors can change this, however, including: • The IA or BD can end the delay early if they determine that the disbursement will not result in financial exploitation. • The IA or BD must extend the delay to 25 business days if Adult Protective Services or the state securities commissioner requests the extension. • A court can extend the delay for as long as it deems appropriate. Access to Records The Model Act requires all records relating to suspected financial exploitation to be made available to Adult Protective Services, as well as law enforcement. (The state securities commissioner already has the right to access these records, because it can access any of a firm’s records.) This includes records of any internal review by the investment adviser (IA) or broker-dealer (BD), as well as records of any transactions that may be connected to financial exploitation. Advance Directives Investment adviser representatives (IARs) should discuss with their clients the usefulness of advance directives, which are legal documents that spell out how the client wishes the investment adviser (IA) to act on their behalf if the client is unable to make decisions because of a hospitalization, cognitive decline, or similar situation. A client who is impaired to the point of being unable to manage their own affairs is said to have diminished capacity. Unfortunately, this is a difficult topic for some clients. No one wants to think about the possibility of enduring this type of impairment. Another reason this discussion may be intimidating for clients is because carrying out the advance directive might require the client to sign a contingent power of attorney. This is a document that legally allows the IA to act on behalf of the
client under conditions specified in the power of attorney. The power of attorney can be narrowly worded so that the IA can only use it to carry out the client’s instructions, and only if the client has diminished capacity. Even still, a client might be nervous about giving any control over their affairs. The North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA) offers the following guidance for broaching this topic with clients: One potential strategy reported to be successful by financial professionals is to engage clients and customers on the topic of planning for medical emergencies generally in lieu of a specific discussion focused only on cognitive decline or financial exploitation. This approach could then grow into a discussion of other advance safeguards, with clients more willing to commit to the designation of their “financial agent” or “in case of” contact should the need arise in the future
Comparison Chart - Broker-Dealer (BD) versus Investment Adviser (IA) Business Practice Rules ZOOM IN
Chapter 3 Summary Video & Chapter 3 Live Question Replay With Expert Tutor
CLICK Continue To Move onto Chapter 4